Published on April 7th, 2014 | by Jesse Yancy0
Local Food: Retro Red Velvet
A really good cake should be a crown jewel in your culinary repertoire. The ruby in my kitchen is a hand-me-down red velvet cake.
Great cakes don’t come out of a box. No, they come from handwork, sacks and shells, from old tried-and-true recipes and those who have made them. Such cakes are not only worthy of serving to family and guests, but they’re also fun to make. Most of the best of them involve complicated procedures that aren’t that time-consuming at all if you’re a dedicated home cook in the first place; it’s good practice, and you get to use kitchenware and ingredients that otherwise simply take up a lot of space. Not only that, but pulling a perfectly-cooked cake out of the oven is a simply unmatchable experience. And after beaming at your creation for a few minutes, you get to decorate, to really show off; the cake is your canvas, and you are the artist who produced this most temporary of masterpieces.
Legend has it that the original recipe for the red velvet cake is from the kitchens of the Waldorf-Astoria, but there’s no solid opinion on that. The cake became popular here sometime after World War II, when the South began to become much more a part of the nation as a whole. Me, I think that the red velvet cake is a variation of the old devil’s food cake and that the name changed because many good religious women were just not going to bring Satan’s bounty to their tables. It has the same texture, for one thing, and while no cocoa is used in the icing, the cake’s primary flavoring is chocolate.
This is a family recipe, one of the dozen or so I still have from my mother’s hand. I’m almost sure she got it from her grandmother Eula, who came from a line of exceptional cooks. Her sister, my Aunt Leila, was (and still is) legendary in certain circles for her cakes, pickles and preserves. They were also all very strict Baptists, and I suspect they were among the ones who would simply not feed their folks devil’s food; given their descendants, they probably had enough devilment to put up with in the first place.
Two elements of the recipe give evidence of its age. First is that it employs what I’ve always heard referred to as a “boiled icing,” meaning an icing that is produced pretty much in the way you would make a sauce or a gravy, by heating starch in a liquid. In some cookbooks, this is referred to as a “roux icing,” but it’s a very raw roux indeed. The advantage to this type of icing is that you don’t have to heat it to ice your cake, and it tastes so much better than that lard and confectioner’s sugar stuff you get at the supermarket. Second is the leavening, which involves that chemistry set action of putting baking soda in a bit of vinegar and watching it foam. The acidic buttermilk in the batter provides additional frothing, but the end result is, well, velvety.
Many of you will probably take issue with the amount of food coloring involved. After all, you could probably dye a bushel of pears pink with the same amount, but try to relax; one of the best parts of making this cake is dribbling that red food coloring into your white batter and swirling it in.
The absolute best part, of course, is eating it.
Batter: 1 cup vegetable shortening, 1 ¼ cup sugar, 2 eggs, 1 teaspoon vanilla flavoring, 2 ¼ cups plain flour, 1 teaspoon salt, 1 tablespoon cocoa, 1 cup buttermilk, 2 ounces red food coloring, 1 teaspoon baking soda and 1 tablespoon vinegar.
Cream shortening and sugar, and add well-beaten eggs and vanilla. Sift flour, salt and cocoa three times. Add dry ingredients alternately with buttermilk. Blend in food coloring. Dissolve soda in vinegar, and fold into batter. Bake in 3 layers at 350 degrees.
Icing: 1 ½ cups milk, 4 ½ tablespoons flour, 1 ½ cups butter (3 sticks), 1 ½ cups sugar, 1 ½ teaspoons vanilla flavoring.
Gradually add milk to flour in double boiler, stirring constantly until it is thicker than pudding. Remove from heat and stir until cooled. Cream butter and sugar for at least ten minutes, then add vanilla and continue creaming until fluffy. Add flour and milk mixture to creamed butter and sugar and beat at least ten minutes until no grains of sugar can be detected. Frost cake and sprinkle with crushed walnuts or pecans.
If you really want it good, wrap it up and let it sit overnight.